I don't know if any of you have heard the headlines, but last Friday a Binghamton University Professor, Richard Antoun, was stabbed to death by a 46 year old PhD student from Saudi Arabia, Abdulsalam al-Zahrani. My condolences go out to the family of Dr. Antoun, may he rest in peace.
This story doesn't appear on GoogleNews as a top headline (you have to search the topic to find the stories). One thing that is apparent is that officials are not unveiling a lot of facts on it. This, I think, has lead many so called journalists to try to play the "Muslim extremist / t e r r o r i s t" theory, and some have even tried to play the card that it was a Muslim going after a Jew. However, from the little information we know, and you have to go to earlier publications in the news, I don't know how people are taking these theories as even somewhat truth.
Fact #1: Muslims on the BU campus avoided al-Zahrani because he made insults about Islam. Here are some quotations from the students.
Fact #4: The mental stability of al-Zahrani is questionable. Interviews by his roommates before the incident shed some light on his behavior patterns well before the murder.
It is clear that al-Zahrani displayed signs of being a psycho and it has nothing to do with whatever his religion may or may not be. When will people realize that there are crazy people out there and their craziness has nothing to do with a religion and all to do with their brains? Will you not use your reason?
Fact #5: Even if al-Zahrani is Muslim, murder is condoned by Islam as explicitly stated in the Qur'an:
I hope these basic facts have made some things clear to all of those conspiracy theorists out there. Little has been made public on this case and people are trying to come up with what the motives could have been. The fact of the matter is that there was probably little to no motive because al-Zahrani is crazy and no one can understand what goes through a mentality disturbed character's mind to justify whatever they do; it runs counter to all reason. From what we do know about al-Zahrani, he does not outwardly display characteristics of a a pious Muslim because of his outward actions, and this brings great doubt about his religious status.
Also, you all spreading lies and fear on the Internet should be ashamed of yourselves. You do not pursue truth, nor do you help the situation. Rather you try to turn lies into fact, you create tension between different groups, and in short you are doing everything against what Dr. Antoun's work was about. You do not make suggestions about how to prevent these situations in the future, but rather you hit at people's emotions to stir hatred. You are out there to make a sensational story just so you can grab more reader's attention so you can get more ad revenue. It is disgusting.
This story doesn't appear on GoogleNews as a top headline (you have to search the topic to find the stories). One thing that is apparent is that officials are not unveiling a lot of facts on it. This, I think, has lead many so called journalists to try to play the "Muslim extremist / t e r r o r i s t" theory, and some have even tried to play the card that it was a Muslim going after a Jew. However, from the little information we know, and you have to go to earlier publications in the news, I don't know how people are taking these theories as even somewhat truth.
Fact #1: Muslims on the BU campus avoided al-Zahrani because he made insults about Islam. Here are some quotations from the students.
"Mohammad Hamasha, another doctoral student from Jordan, recalled an encounter with Al-Zahrani on a bus in Johnson City a year ago. Hamasha said he addressed Al-Zahrani with a traditional Muslim greeting meaning 'peace be upon you.' He said Al-Zahrani responded, 'you are the brother of a (expletive).'"
"'He insulted Islam, my religion, which is a good religion,' said Samer Salameh, a master's degree candidate, who said Al-Zahrani used the phrase 'garbage in Johnson City' in an apparent reference to a local mosque. 'That is not acting like a Muslim.'"Fact #2: The Islamic Organization of the Southern Tier (the only masjid in that area) made a statement that al-Zahrani had no affiliation whatsoever with the masjid. In fact in a statement from their website, they said it was Dr. Antoun who was involved with their Interfaith Outreach programs (see Fact #3), and members of the Islamic community held a memorial this past Sunday for Antoun.
"'He [al-Zahrani] was not affiliated with us at all. At the time of the incident we were here in our most sacred time to pray here and he was not and never has been in our program,' said Imam Kopuz."
"Kopuz and Entisham Siddiqui, president of the Islamic Organization of the Southern Tier, addressed about 70 people who attended a brief remembrance for Antoun Sunday at the mosque. They described him as a friend to the local Muslim community who often partook in events to expand religious tolerance and cooperation among faiths. 'We will sadly miss him,' Kopuz said. 'He was an embodiment of light and knowledge.'"Fact #3: The memorial fund and funeral service will be at the Unitarian Universalist Church in Binghamton, NY. You can read more about Unitarian Univeralists here. If Richard Antoun was Jewish, like some reports out there are saying, wouldn't his funeral be at a Jewish Temple? In Judaism some argue that even if you break away from the religion it doesn't change your status as a Jew. To make this act anti-Semetic, wouldn't you have to prove that 1. Dr. Antoun was Jewish, 2. that al-Zahrani knew about the intimate details of Dr. Antoun's faith history, and 3. that al-Zahrani motive was based upon his knowledge of Dr. Antoun being Jewish? It doesn't make sense to make after the fact conclusions. The Distric Attorney of Binghamton has stated that religion was not part of the motive. Dr. Antoun was active with many faiths, and all we know is that he was member of the Unitarian Universalist Church.
Fact #4: The mental stability of al-Zahrani is questionable. Interviews by his roommates before the incident shed some light on his behavior patterns well before the murder.
"Souleyman Sukho, a Senegalese doctoral student at BU, said during the three weeks the men lived together, Al-Zahrani 'came at me with a knife.' 'He asked me if I was afraid of dying,"'Sukho said. 'Then he went into his room. I told him, 'don't ask me the question if you don't want to hear my answer.'"One of his roommates said that Al-Zahrani said that he felt persecuted, but the interview doesn't specify about what he felt persecuted against. His nationality? His age? His accent? Some have twisted this into al-Zahrani felt persecuted because of his religion, but from what we've looked at I don't see how that could be because he is not affliated with the masjid, in one report students said he was smoking during Ramadan (which means that you've broken your fast intentionally), and he would swear at Muslims when they would say "Peace be with you" to him. JUST BECAUSE YOU HAVE A LAST NAME IN ARABIC DOESN'T MEAN YOU ARE MUSLIM. When are people going to get this through their heads?
"'He would be sitting here on the sofa and just blurt out, 'I just feel like destroying the world,' Pena said. 'He would just make weird remarks. He comes off calm (but) he could flip in a second,"'Pena said."
It is clear that al-Zahrani displayed signs of being a psycho and it has nothing to do with whatever his religion may or may not be. When will people realize that there are crazy people out there and their craziness has nothing to do with a religion and all to do with their brains? Will you not use your reason?
Fact #5: Even if al-Zahrani is Muslim, murder is condoned by Islam as explicitly stated in the Qur'an:
"17:33 (Asad) And do not take any human being's life -[the life] which God has willed to be, sacred-otherwise than in [the pursuit of] justice. Hence, if anyone has been slain wrongfully, We have empowered the defender of his rights [to exact a just retribution] ; but even so, let him not exceed the bounds of equity in [retributive] killing. [And as for him who has been slain wrongfully -] behold, he is indeed succoured [by God] !"Concluding Remarks:
I hope these basic facts have made some things clear to all of those conspiracy theorists out there. Little has been made public on this case and people are trying to come up with what the motives could have been. The fact of the matter is that there was probably little to no motive because al-Zahrani is crazy and no one can understand what goes through a mentality disturbed character's mind to justify whatever they do; it runs counter to all reason. From what we do know about al-Zahrani, he does not outwardly display characteristics of a a pious Muslim because of his outward actions, and this brings great doubt about his religious status.
Also, you all spreading lies and fear on the Internet should be ashamed of yourselves. You do not pursue truth, nor do you help the situation. Rather you try to turn lies into fact, you create tension between different groups, and in short you are doing everything against what Dr. Antoun's work was about. You do not make suggestions about how to prevent these situations in the future, but rather you hit at people's emotions to stir hatred. You are out there to make a sensational story just so you can grab more reader's attention so you can get more ad revenue. It is disgusting.

